Blood: Because of the many attacks that heal for a percentage of the dmg you cause the best weapons for any Blood specced DK should be obvious…HIGH Top End Dmg higher crits mean more health to ya letting you have a better Survivability and saving the healers mana in instances since they have one less person to heal…
Frost: high STR and stamina are DEFINATELY good to have for any tank however a DK can benefit the most because they convert STR into parry rating… The way i see it if you have 2 1h weapons that you are tanking with it might be ok to have a moderate speed weapon for your mainhand because of instant attacks…however for your off hand since other than stats and that extra rune OH is next to useless a fast OH could be handy for extra dmg and if you aren’t useing swordbreaking it may help whatever is on that weapon proc a bit more…of course most tanking weapons are pretty fast anyways so if you come across a faster weapon for your main hand go ahead and take it more swings more dmg more threat. And yes if the weapon has the right stats you can tank some instances with a two hander but 1 handers that give def rating armor resilience dodge or anything like that are usually preferred but if you are capped in each department without the weapon a two hander could be good to throw in extra dmg.
Unholy: Unfortunately i have yet to do anything deep in unholy before i respecced to frost since most of your dmg can come from your ghoul gargoyle and diseases a 2h or DW build can be equally effective…many people prefer to DW for unholy however and although i am not sure it seems to increase DPS a fair bit for them…dont quote me on this
If anyone has any corrections or additions post them and share your thoughts….be nice(ish)!ok being nice.
most of what you say isnt correct. dw has some specific builds in which it works, but only as dps. if you or any other dk is tanking with dw they/you are wrong. the reasons being a) your rune strike hits for less with a 1h wep and it is most of your threat.
b)you need much more hit rating in order to not miss which is huge for a tank
c) fast weps = more swings = more boss parries = parryjibbed. not all bosses parryjib though but when it happens its a problem.
does not matter what tree you spec, dps will always benefit from blood pressence (although some dw specs use unholy pressence), but it isnt enough to not need healing. atm unholy and frost specs can both be very effective tanks, blood is a little behind and unholy, blood, and dw specs do the best dps.I’ve played Unholy all the yway to lvl 68 (currently) and I would say that a slow 2H is best since your damage comes from instant strikes and Rune Strike. when watching my DPS meter my auto attacks stand for 13%% of my damage, my Rune strikes is 20%%, My diseases is about 40%% and the direct damage of instant strikes (Plague Strike, Blood Strike, etc) is 27%%.
Now the reason for my Disease damage is because I normaly pull 3 mobs at once and AOE them down.
